Our Specialties

Explore our premium collection of trading cards and collectibles

NFL

Premium football cards

NBA

Elite basketball cards

MLB

Classic baseball cards

NHL

Rare hockey cards

Pokemon

Collectible Pokemon cards
Our Philosophy

Building Excellence

We are committed to curating the finest collectibles

with integrity, passion, and dedication to our community.

Quality First

Every card is carefully authenticated and graded to ensure you receive only the highest quality collectibles.

Trust & Transparency

We build lasting relationships through honest communication and transparent business practices.

Rare & Exclusive

We focus on providing rare and exclusive cards in our inventory, giving you the best place to find your next gem

This Month's MVP's

Every month the team at Benchmark brings you a high end MVP caliber selection to look through...don't miss out!

Premium Collectibles

Enter the Premium Vault where you can find our highest end cards to redefine your collection or sell your top end cards for big returns

Shop Now

Upcoming Events

Meet us at these exclusive collectibles events
September 12, 2026

Michigan Card Expo

Novi, MI
Join us in Novi Michigan for one of the states best card shows. Expanded table space for premium inventory, SSP's and buying activity.
September 25-27, 2026

Philly Card Show

Oaks, PA
One of the country's largest card shows. Benchmark will be there and in full force with some of the best cards out there.
October 17, 2026

Detroit Card Show

Waterford, MI
Benchmark will be gunning at the Detroit Card show in Waterford. New inventory of high end cards expected. Come join us.
November 20-22, 2026

Chicago Sports Spectacular

Chicago, IL
Another national show that will not disappoint. The Benchmark crew will be in full force and our inventory will be second to none.

Looking to sell a card or collection?

We make it easy to get top dollar for your premium cards and collections.
1

Tell Us What You Have

Fill out the form with details and photos of your card or collection. The more detail, the faster we can respond with a real number.
2

We Evaluate and Make an Offer

Our team checks current market comps, population reports, and grading history to put together a firm cash offer or consignment terms; usually within 1-2 business days.
3

You Choose: Sell Outright or Consign

Take a cash offer on the spot, or let us list and sell it for you on consignment with a transparent commission split. Either way, no pressure.
4

Get paid fast

Outright sales are paid immediately upon agreement. Consigned items are paid out as soon as they sell.

Ready to get started?

We're building a direct connection to Card Ladder's market data so you can get an instant estimated value range for your card the moment you enter its name and grade; before our team even looks at it. Until that's fully live, submit your card details in the form and we'll pull comps manually and get back to you fast; usually same day. (Form Below)

The Form: Selling a Card or Collection?

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Note: File uploads in contact forms require additional setup. Please include a link to your photos in the details field above, or we'll follow up via email for photos.

Meet our leadership team

The people behind our success
Mike Laicaino

Mike Laicaino

Co-Founder

Mike Laiacono | Co-Founder

734-718-1124 | mike@benchmarkcardco.com

 

Clint Babcock

Clint Babcock

Co-Founder

Clint Babcock | Co-Founder

734-678-4290 | clint@benchmarkcardco.com

Simon Babcock

Simon Babcock

Managing Partner

Simon Babcock | Managing Partner

734-560-2666 | simon@benchmarkcardco.com